There is one candy The Picky Eater and I agree on—Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups. We buy the mini ones and keep them in a 1930s refrigerator-ware dish made by The Hall China Company for Westinghouse. However, these little bites of chocolate-peanut butter goodness don’t stay around our house for long.
These treats are scrumptious! Since the recipe calls for graham cracker crumbs and chocolate, I added some mini-marshmallows on top of half the recipe for s’mores-like flavor. The Picky Eater loved the non-marshmallow ones—he gave them his famous three-thumbs-up! (So good he needs another thumb. He’s so cute.) Now we have a new candy for our vintage dish.
You can find the recipe here, and be sure to check our more of Mary’s delicious creations.